TNL.net is designed for modern browsers but the content is still readable in older ones. If you want to ensure the best experience, please install a browser that was developed after 2009.

tnl.net

The iPhone is here

So it’s offi­cial: Apple now is a phone man­u­fac­turer. With the announce­ment of the Apple iPhone, we can now finally assess that new prod­uct and I have to say, color me impressed. The com­pany has man­aged to over­come a lot of the prob­lems sur­round­ing exist­ing mobile phones and cre­ated a device that is close to what geeks like myself want: 2 megapixel cam­era, MP3 player, video player, phone with inte­grated address book, cal­en­dar, email, web browser, SMS, notepad, google maps, and sup­port for other wid­gets, which makes the whole plat­form more extensible.

It’s a very smart move on the part of Apple, which high­lighted the change in the way the com­pany is oper­at­ing by chang­ing its name from Apple Com­puter, Inc. to Apple, Inc. , reflect­ing the fact that they are no longer just a com­puter company.There were a few inter­est­ing items of inter­est, though.

For starters, no men­tion of how the phone will sync up with a com­puter. Are we to assume that it’s Mac Only or will it syn­chro­nize with com­put­ers run­ning Win­dows too? If so, does that mean that a new set of appli­ca­tions will be avail­able to Win­dows users to sync their address book, cal­en­dar and email with sys­tems like Out­look or will the device require to man­age those things specif­i­cally using Apple appli­ca­tions on Windows?

The other thing that was inter­est­ing is the announce­ment that the phone will run on quad-band GSM and will be using EDGE net­work. This means that the phone will get decent but not great data ser­vice. Per­fect for email and light web brows­ing but not quite fast enough for video stream­ing. How­ever, the intro­duc­tion of WiFi in the device, which many other com­pa­nies have avoided for fear of los­ing bat­tery capac­ity, could take care of that.

The other inter­est­ing thing is that the oper­at­ing sys­tem on this device is OSX. This seems to point out to two pos­si­ble issues: First, what does that mean for Por­talPlayer, which has tra­di­tion­ally pro­vided Apple with the oper­at­ing sys­tem (embed­ded on a chip) for the iPod? The sec­ond ques­tion is what does it mean in gen­eral: What Apple has intro­duced is basi­cally a mac in a small form fac­tor, which could eas­ily com­pete with the UMPC spec­i­fi­ca­tions intro­duced by Microsoft. It’s pretty clear that Apple has a lot of plans in the future for that device but they didn’t say much about the sig­nif­i­cance of OSX, pro­vid­ing it almost as an aside (and what does it mean for the next ver­sion of OSX, which was not men­tioned dur­ing this keynote at all, a sur­pris­ing omis­sion in itself.)

Who loses?

Judg­ing from the reac­tion on the stock mar­ket, it’s pretty obvi­ous to see who loses: Palm (mak­ers of the Treo), RIM (mak­ers of the Black­berry), and Motorola and Nokia will obvi­ously not be thrilled with the entrance of Apple in this mar­ket. The exclu­sive deal with AT&T (ooops, sorry, Cin­gu­lar) will also have a neg­a­tive impact on Ver­i­zon, Sprint, and T-mobile as Ver­i­zon will see a num­ber of users switch­ing to them in order to get their hands on this device (in infor­mal dis­cus­sion with a num­ber of fel­low geeks, the dis­ad­van­tages of mov­ing to Cin­gu­lar were far out­weighted by the cool­ness of this device).

Let’s take a quick look at specs and see how the dif­fer­ence devices fare against this new entrant:

Apple Motorola Nokia Palm Rim Sam­sung
Con­sumer Device iPhone Q E-62 Treo 750 Black­berry Pearl Black­jack
Price $499–599 $299 $149 $199 $199 $199
Dimen­sions 4.5 x 2.4 x .46 inches 4.33 x 2.52 x .45 inches 4.61 x 2.76 x .63 inches 4.44 x 2.3 x .8 inches 4.2 x 1.97 x .57 inches 4.4 x 2.3 x .5 inches
Weight 4.8 ounces 4.06 ounces 5 ounces 5.4 ounces 3.1 ounces 3.5 ounces
Screen size 3.5 inches 2.4 inches N/A N/A N/A 2.3 inches
Screen res­o­lu­tion 320 by 480 (at 160 pp) 320 by 240 (65k colors) 320 x 240 (16 mil­lion colors) 240 x 240 (65k colors) 240 x 260 (65k colors) 320 x 240 (65k colors)
Oper­at­ing System OSX Win­dows Mobile Sym­bian Win­dows Mobile RIM Win­dows Mobile
Stor­age 4GB or 8GB 64 MB + Min­iSD up to 2GB 80MB + min­iSD up to 2GB 128MB + SD up to 2GB 64 MB + Min­iSD up to 2GB 128 MB + MicroSD up to 2GB
Phone Ser­vice GSM Quad-band (MHz: 850, 900, 1800, 1900) CDMA dual band (Mhz: 800 and 1900) GSM Quad-band (MHz: 850, 900, 1800, 1900) GSM Quad-band (MHz: 850, 900, 1800, 1900) GSM Quad-band (MHz: 850, 900, 1800, 1900) GSM Quad-band (MHz: 850, 900, 1800, 1900)
Data Ser­vice Wi-Fi (802.11b/g) + EDGE 1x-EVDO/aGPS GPRS + EDGE GPRS + EDGE + UMTS tri-band (850, 1900, and 2100) GPRS + EDGE UMTS/HSDPA dual bank (Mhz: 850 and 1900)
Blue­tooth 2.0 2.0 2.0 1.2 2.0 2.0
Cam­era 2MPP 1.3MPP N/A 1.3MPP 1.3MPP N/A
Bat­tery talk time: 5 hours / other: 16 hours talk time: 4 hours / standby: 212 hours talk time: 5.5 hours / standby 14 days (336 hours) talk time: 4 hours / standby: 250 hours talk time: 3.5 hours / standby: 15 days (360 hours) talk time: 5.5 hours / standby:11 days (264 hours)

So look­ing at it, this phone is pretty expen­sive (you pay for the Apple pre­mium) but packs a lot more fea­tures than other phones in the same cat­e­gory. It’s got a bet­ter cam­era, more mem­ory and a larger screen as well as WiFi. It’s talk time (for the cat­e­gory) is actu­ally pretty good (only bested by Nokia’s E-62) and it is a lit­tle heav­ier than the com­pe­ti­tion. For a first entry in the mar­ket, I’d say that Apple has a win­ner on its hands.

Originally published on January 9, 2007 in Business, Technology . You may find related thoughts pieces under the following terms: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

  • Pingback: Medley

  • Robert NIchol­son

    Apple missed an oppor­tu­nity here to deliv­ery audio/video chat over Wifi. Clearly Cin­gu­lar wouldn’t like it but their 3g net­work doesn’t even sup­port video call­ing. Apple had an oppor­tu­nity put a smart isight in the phone and give peo­ple an VoIP expe­ri­ence unseen today when using wifi con­nec­tions but instead have pan­dered to Cin­gu­lar. This phone isn’t going to sell very well out­side the US where cus­tomers expect 3g like fea­tures today not tomorrow.

  • http://www.gsmarena.com/o2-phones-30.php Robert Sox

    You really need to com­pare this to the O2 line of phones, these are all dumbphones

    http://www.gsmarena.com/o2-phones-30.php

  • Pingback: Circa CFD

  • Isidore

    This is a phone for Amer­ica. The US has a seri­ously dis­func­tional mobile phone mar­ket and this shows in this prod­uct. The inter­face is great unless of course you want to write emails or send texts– the palm like hand­writ­ing recog­ni­tion of the sony eric­s­son smart phones is surely faster than hunt and peck, whether on a tra­di­tional key­pad or a vir­tual one. And as for no 3G speed, it just won’t hack it in Europe for web brows­ing. But the basic con­cept is great– the next gen­er­a­tion should be a real contender.

  • Heleen

    I;m in Europe where we text a lot. I would not move to a touch pad screen because I can text with teh phone in my pocket by feel­ing the keys. I would’t be able to do that with the iPhone. I have a Nokia N70 which works won­ders as a per­sonal phone (text/camera) and a busi­ness phone (email/browsing). And for a frac­tion of the cost.

    Also I’d be wor­ried about scratch­ing the big screen. Obvi­souly Steve doesn’t keep his in a handbag!

  • Ram­ses

    One pos­si­ble rea­son for the lack of 3G is that Apple doesn’t own any of the patents required to build and sell prod­ucts that adhere to the 3G stan­dards. Nokia, Motorola, Eric­s­son and Qual­comm own the patents and ahare them through a pool, where they pay only small net pay­ments to each other.

    One of the key rea­sons Sony paired with Eric­s­son in the phone busi­ness was this very rea­son. I don’t know the specifics any arrange­ments Apple may have, but I’d assume that the same logic applies here that applied at Sony: if Apple added 3G to the iPhone it would have to hand over around 10% of the sell­ing price for each unit to Nokia, Motorola & co. This applies to EDGE too, by the way — Apple is going to pay roy­al­ties to the estab­lished vendors.

    Tak­ing the N95 as an exam­ple, it’s data rate is around ten times faster than the iPhone owing to HSDPA, which comes in handy when down­load­ing of streaming.

  • Tom B

    The fact that 3 of your 6 exam­ple run Win­dows CE demon­strates the exe­crable, sorry state of the cur­rent “smart” phone mar­ket­place. I encour­age peo­ple to watch the iPhone seg­ment of Steve Job’s keynote– it’s a riv­et­ing demo. These babies look pretty amaz­ing. I bet they WILL fol­low it up with the first practical/desirable UPMC.

  • Pingback: E-Scribe News

  • Pingback: Utterly Boring - Surfing The Web So You Don't Have To

  • Pingback: Transparent Agenda

  • Pingback: Welcome to TNL.net

  • Pingback: iTRIXX

  • Pingback: Of Interest

  • Pingback: iPhone 2: More than meets the eye

  • Pingback: Safari: Apple’s New Platform?